Mayita

by | Jun 26, 2025 | Historic Downtown, Mexican

Mayita Restaurant logo featuring bold typography and vibrant Mexican-inspired design elements

this business has a rating of 4.9

Mayita in St. Augustine: Authentic Mexican Flavors with a Waterfront View

If you’re searching for authentic Mexican food in St. Augustine, look no further than Mayita, a hidden gem nestled along Avenida Menendez with stunning views of the Matanzas Bay. This vibrant eatery has quickly become a local favorite for its bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and warm hospitality.

A Taste of Mexico in the Heart of the Nation’s Oldest City

Mayita offers a refreshing take on traditional Mexican street food, blending slow-cooked meats, house-made salsas, and tropical drinks in a casual, family-friendly setting. Whether you’re a local or a tourist exploring the historic district, this spot delivers a culinary experience that feels both comforting and exciting.

14 Avenida Menendez
St. Augustine, FL 32084

Visit their website

Menu

904.429.9205

Hours:

Monday: 11:00 – 9:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 – 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 – 9:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 – 9:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 – 10:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM- 9:00 PM

 

Fresh guacamole and crispy tortilla chips at Mayita Restaurant in St. Augustine
Shrimp fajita street tacos with grilled peppers and onions at Mayita Restaurant in St. Augustine
Chicken enchiladas topped with melted cheese and fresh cilantro at Mayita Restaurant in St. Augustine
Assorted tacos with fresh toppings at Mayita Restaurant in St. Augustine
Exterior view of Mayita Restaurant in St. Augustine with colorful signage and historic bayfront setting

Must-Try Menu Highlights

  • Agua Fresca: Light, fruity, and incredibly refreshing—perfect for warm Florida afternoons. The pineapple and mango flavors are especially popular.

  • Taco Flight: Can’t decide? Try them all. The taco flight lets you sample a variety of fillings, from citrus-marinated pork to grilled chicken and vegetarian options.

  • Homemade Hot Sauce: Not for the faint of heart! This fiery condiment is made in-house and adds a serious kick to any dish.

  • Fresh Plantains: A rare find in the area, these golden slices are sweet, crispy, and unforgettable.

  • Horchata & Guacamole: Creamy, spiced horchata and fresh guac round out the perfect meal.

While the beloved esquites (Mexican street corn) are currently off the menu, many regulars are hoping for its return.

Why Locals Love It

From Sarasota to St. Augustine, Southern locals rave about Mayita’s authenticity. One of my recent visitors shared after I had recommended Mayita, “As a Southern local from Sarasota, I can say this place is the real deal.” Another friend added, “We’re locals and we’ll definitely be coming back.”

The service is consistently praised as friendly and fast, especially during lunch hours when the atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming. Whether you’re dining solo, with a partner, or bringing the whole family, Mayita makes everyone feel at home.

Location & Atmosphere

Located just steps from the Castillo de San Marcos, Mayita offers a prime waterfront location that’s perfect for a scenic lunch or sunset dinner. Guests have even reported spotting dolphins in the bay while enjoying their meals!

map to Mayita