Lala’s Creamery

by | Jun 13, 2025 | Desserts, West of US-1 / SR-16 Corridor

this business is rated at four point eight stars

If you’re searching for handcrafted, organic ice cream in St. Augustine, look no further than Lala’s Creamery. Nestled inside the mall at 2121 US-1, this hidden gem offers a personalized ice cream experience that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more.

Why Lala’s Creamery Stands Out

Lala’s Creamery has earned a reputation for its triple crown of excellence—a superior quality product, outstanding customer service, and a unique, interactive experience. Every scoop is made fresh right in front of you, ensuring the highest quality and flavor.

Freshly Made Ice Cream with Unique Flavors

One of the highlights of Lala’s Creamery is its rolled ice cream, crafted with organic ingredients and a variety of creative flavors. Popular choices include:

  • Monkey Business – A delightful blend of banana and chocolate.

  • The Cookie Jar – A must-try for cookie lovers.

  • Beet Cherries and Lime – A refreshing and unexpected combination.

2121 US-1
St. Augustine, FL 32086

904.209.5098

Hours:

Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 1:00 PM- 7:00 PM
Thursday: 1:00 PM- 7:00 PM
Friday: 1:00 PM- 7:00 PM
Saturday: 1:00 PM- 7:00 PM
Sunday: 1:00 PM- 4:00 PM

 

A decadent slice of pie paired with a cup of creamy ice cream from Lala’s Creamery in St. Augustine, topped with fluffy whipped cream and rich chocolate drizzle.
A creamy scoop of ice cream topped with fluffy whipped cream in a branded cup from Lala’s Creamery, St. Augustine. The dessert sits on a pastel-colored counter, capturing the shop’s nostalgic charm.
Two cups of handcrafted rolled ice cream from Lala’s Creamery in St. Augustine, topped with fresh fruit and drizzled with syrup. The vibrant presentation highlights the shop’s artisanal approach to frozen treats.
A decadent cup of ice cream from Lala’s Creamery in St. Augustine, topped with fluffy whipped cream and rich chocolate drizzle, served in the shop’s signature cup.
The charming interior of Lala’s Creamery in St. Augustine, featuring pastel-colored walls, vintage-inspired décor, and a welcoming counter displaying handcrafted ice cream flavors.

A Personal Touch

The owner and staff at Lala’s Creamery go above and beyond to create a welcoming atmosphere. Customers rave about the artistry of the ice cream-making process, describing it as satisfying to watch and worth the wait.

A Few Things to Keep in Mind

While Lala’s Creamery is a top-rated ice cream shop, some visitors have noted that its location inside the mall can be tricky to find. Additionally, double-check the hours before visiting, as there have been occasional discrepancies between Google Maps and actual closing times.

Plan Your Visit

Whether you’re a local foodie or a visitor exploring St. Augustine, Lala’s Creamery is a must-visit destination for organic, handcrafted ice cream. Stop by and treat yourself to a one-of-a-kind dessert experience!

map to Lala's Creamery